28 W Green, Heighington Village, Newton Aycliffe DL5 6PE

About This Pub

Ah, The Bay Horse Inn – it's one of those pubs that just wraps you up in that classic English charm the moment you step inside. Picture this: oak beams overhead, a cosy fire crackling away in the colder months, and a genuine country feel that's been going strong since 1818. The team there, led by Tony and Diane, are always so welcoming, making you feel like you're catching up with old mates rather than just popping in for a drink. Their beer and ale lineup is brilliant, with rotating guest options and award-winners that any ale enthusiast would rave about, alongside a solid choice of wines and whiskeys to suit all tastes. And the food? Oh, it's a treat – home-cooked dishes like the best fish and chips I've heard of in ages, or a hearty steak pie that's full of flavour, plus they've nailed the gluten-free stuff without losing that proper pub grub vibe. The outdoor seating is a nice touch for when the weather plays ball, giving you a bit of that rural village escape. But, let's be honest, it's not all pint-perfect; it can get packed to the rafters, especially on weekends, which means waits for service that might leave you twiddling your thumbs. A couple of reviewers mentioned surprises with menu details, like dressings that aren't flagged up, and while it's on the up, it does have that lived-in look that might not appeal if you're after something more polished. All in all, though, I'd say it's worth a visit for a laid-back afternoon or evening – just book ahead and go with the flow for the full experience!

Pros and Cons

Pros
  • The cosy, traditional atmosphere with classic oak beams and a roaring fire makes you feel right at home, especially on a chilly evening.
  • They've got a fantastic selection of award-winning beers, real ales, gins, wines, and malt whiskeys – perfect for a proper pint or a sophisticated sip.
  • The food is spot on; think delicious home-cooked meals like scrumptious fish and chips, tasty steak pies, and a brilliant carvery that's always a hit.
  • Friendly staff who make you feel welcome, and they've got great options for those with dietary needs, like gluten-free choices that don't skimp on flavour.
  • Outdoor seating areas out front and back are lovely for soaking up the rural vibes, especially on a sunny day in the village.
Cons
  • It can get really busy, leading to long waits for drinks or food, which might put a dampener on your visit if you're in a rush.
  • Some menu items aren't always clearly described, like unexpected dressings on salads, which could surprise you if you're picky about that sort of thing.
  • The place has had its ups and downs over the years, and while it's improving, it might still feel a tad dated in spots compared to more modern spots.
  • Food service stops fairly early, especially on Sundays, so if you're planning a late meal, you might need to adjust your timings.

Contact Information

28 W Green, Heighington Village, Newton Aycliffe DL5 6PE
+441325312312
Pub
Open Now

Opening Hours

Monday (Today)12:00 - 23:00
Tuesday12:00 - 23:00
Wednesday12:00 - 23:00
Thursday12:00 - 23:00
Friday12:00 - 23:00
Saturday12:00 - 23:00
Sunday12:00 - 23:00

Location

Recent Reviews

This pub was once a great place for drinks but became a bit rundown as the management changed. It appears to be a little better cared for these days. Does a lot of meals and has outdoor seating both front and back. It was pretty busy on this Sunday afternoon, even though the sun never really came out.
PM
Paul Mckenna
Brilliant new gluten-free options, best fish and chips I’ve had in years! Such a lovely place, always friendly staff, a relaxed traditional country pub, and properly scrummy food. This huge steamed fish came in a crispy gluten-free batter with chunky chips that had the perfect crispy edges. Absolutely gorgeous (and this was the small portion!). Highly recommend!
FF
Fin Fox
We popped here on the way home for some food, I ordered the steak pie with homemade chips and garden peas, it was super tasty! My husband ordered the chicken parmo with chips and salad which he also enjoyed. Salad was fresh but covered in a mustard dressing which he doesn’t like and it wasn’t stated on the menu. The staff were lovely and attentive, the place itself needs a good clean, which was a bit of a let down. It’s very outdated but I don’t mind that for an old country pub but the place was quiet and had plenty of staff that could be going around just giving it a simple clean.
B
bexyera
Very hectic today ages waiting for our drinks and dessert, think a staff member failed to show up. Always love the carvery.
LW
Lesley wood
My husband and I went here for lunch. Before we went we checked their menu out on there website all looked very nice. We haven't been here for a very long time we used to go where we were courting which was over 35 years ago and haven't been since till today, the place looks exactly the same just a bit worse for wear very sticky tables and worn seats that all could do with some TLC. Food was good value for money husband had the Black and blue burger and I had the black and blue parmo pictures attached. There were four things on the menu that weren't available! and the desert menu that was on the website had Churros on which was to be honest the main reason we went and well they are now not on their menu they just haven't updated the website 😕
LS
Lisa Stark

Nearby Pubs - Perfect Pub Crawl

Discover the 5 closest pubs to this location for an ideal pub crawl experience.

The George & Dragon
The George & Dragon

4 E Green, Heighington Village, Newton Aycliffe DL5 6PP

90/100 0.3mi
The Bay Horse Middridge
The Bay Horse Middridge

42 South Side, Middridge, Newton Aycliffe DL5 7JD

90/100 2.4mi
The Burtree Inn
The Burtree Inn

Burtree Gate, Darlington DL2 2XZ

90/100 2.7mi
The Aviator Gin Bar
The Aviator Gin Bar

Hangar, 18 Northfield Way, Newton Aycliffe DL5 6EJ

91/100 2.8mi
Scout Centre
Scout Centre

Bluebell Way, Newton Aycliffe DL5 7PW

83/100 2.9mi