9 Smithy Wood Rd, Thorpe Hesley, Rotherham S61 2SE

About This Pub

Ah, The Barley – it's one of those pubs that just feels like a proper gem in Thorpe Hesley, with a solid reputation built on tasty grub and attentive folks behind the bar. From the reviews, it's clear that the food steals the show; imagine tucking into a pie that's usually a winner or those lamb chops that one person called one of the best meals they've had – it's all about those flavours that keep you coming back. The staff really shine too, with mentions of Ellie, the manager, and others like Angela and Izzy making sure everything's spot on, from seating you quickly to checking if you've got what you need. It's got that cosy atmosphere perfect for meeting mates, and with a good range of drinks on tap, it's easy to settle in for the evening. On the flip side, though, it's not all smooth sailing – there was that one tale of poor service where a meal arrived late and cold, leaving someone frustrated and unable to enjoy their night properly. Still, with most feedback being overwhelmingly positive, I'd say it's worth a punt; just keep in mind that, like any local spot, it might have an off day. Overall, if you're after a reliable place for a bite and a bevvy, The Barley's got plenty going for it, but maybe pop in with realistic expectations for a balanced experience.

Pros and Cons

Pros
  • The food here is absolutely spot on – think tender lamb chops and flavoursome chicken shish kebab that leave you wanting more, based on what folks are raving about.
  • The staff are a real highlight, always going the extra mile with friendly service and little touches like checking on your order to make sure it's just right.
  • It's got a welcoming vibe with a good selection of draught drinks and a variety of dishes, making it a great spot for a relaxed catch-up over a meal.
Cons
  • Service can be a bit inconsistent at times, with some experiences involving long waits for food or items getting forgotten, which puts a damper on things.
  • There have been a few gripes about the food not always hitting the mark, like overcooked steaks or cold sauces, so it might not be perfect every visit.

Contact Information

9 Smithy Wood Rd, Thorpe Hesley, Rotherham S61 2SE
+441142461110
Pub
Open Now

Opening Hours

Monday (Today)09:00 - 22:00
Tuesday09:00 - 22:00
Wednesday09:00 - 22:00
Thursday09:00 - 22:00
Friday09:00 - 22:00
Saturday09:00 - 22:30
Sunday09:00 - 20:30

Location

Recent Reviews

This experience has been very good, mainly made by Ellie. My meal the Lamb chops was one of the best meals I have had. So flavoursome and Elli made sure I got my mushrooms. We normally have the pie which we love but since changing it there is too much pastry. Thank you Barley
KA
Kay Annan
Poor service and average food, 2 of us ordered one meal came out and had been eaten completely before the second arrived at our table. When it finally arrived (mixed grill) the steak was over cooked the peppercorn sauce cold and forgot my onion rings, I had no chance to voice this to the waiters as they was non existent around our table even though the plates was sat there for half an hour after we finished. Put some fancy pictures on there website and charge a premium for it by the looks, will not be returning 👎🏻
JT
John Tickle
Went today to meet a friend, got there at 5:00pm and it was very quiet. Did wait at the bar for a while waiting to be seated but not a problem. I think it was the manager came out, showed me to my table and asked if I wanted a drink. He was very pleasant and helpful. My friend arrived and we ordered our food. Good service and food. Asked several times if we needed anything and if everything was okay. When we left at about 7:30pm it was quite busy which is a good sign on a week day. Will definitely return.
CT
Cheryl Tough
First time visit 24/04/25 and it won't be the last. Beautiful place, great variety of dishes to choose from and a good selection of draught drinks. The food was exceptional 👍
PW
Paul Wilson
Had a lovely meal tonight, chicken shish kebab….highly recommend! Also 2 x ham & chips with egg & pineapple (the other 2 guests)! Fabulous service from Angela and Izzy, even checking if there was any honeycomb cheesecake…..to die for!!! Been her several times and have never been let down, will most definitely be back! Thankyou all
TW
Tracey Waterman

Nearby Pubs - Perfect Pub Crawl

Discover the 5 closest pubs to this location for an ideal pub crawl experience.

The Travellers
The Travellers

Travellers Inn, 9 Smithy Wood Rd, Thorpe Hesley, Rotherham S61 2SE

87/100 0.0mi
The Ball
The Ball

1 Hesley Bar, Thorpe Hesley, Rotherham S61 2PW

90/100 0.3mi
The Red Lion
The Red Lion

1 Brook Hill, Thorpe Hesley, Rotherham S61 2PY

87/100 0.9mi
The Horse & Tiger
The Horse & Tiger

3 Brook Hill, Thorpe Hesley, Rotherham S61 2QA

92/100 1.0mi
Meadow Farm - Farmhouse Inns
Meadow Farm - Farmhouse Inns

Nether Ln, Ecclesfield, Sheffield S35 9ZX

84/100 1.1mi